So Long Skinny - Star! Magazine

[miss_perfect]

ok, if janet is 160 lbs in that pic, im a monkey's uncle. looks like a lot more to me.
and how the hell would they know these numbers? they're just pulling them out of their asses.

Yeah, like those "celebrity BMI's." They are totally fabricated.

[Algernon]

omg they are soooo off on the "fat" weights and probably the skinny ones too! The skinny weights are listed as too high and the "fat" weights are too high too, what do they we are stupid and now that those girls see this they're just gonna fet skinny again!
LIndz "fat" more likely 120lbs
Jessica "fat" more likely 115lbs
whitney "fat" more likely 130lbs cause shes taller
and Daryl hannah's prob right though cause she's tall too
and I think thats just a really bad pic of poor Janet but she's probably up there in weight too but she's a shorty so more like 160lbs.

I know! What stupid people are making up these weights? The one that stuck out to me is Jessica. No WAY IN HELL does she weigh 135 at 5'3" in that pic. Although....are huge boobs heavy?

[muchlove]

I know! What stupid people are making up these weights? The one that stuck out to me is Jessica. No WAY IN HELL does she weigh 135 at 5'3" in that pic. Although....are huge boobs heavy?

Not THAT heavy. An ex-friend put her on a food scale once... she was a DD and they weighed something like two pounds each.

[Laurent]

I think Janet looks bigger than 160lbs. She's relatively short, but she still looks floofier than that.

[calendargurl]

she HAS to be more than 160...i have a friend who's about 5'5 and ways 164 and Janet is waaaaay bigger than she is.

[EDISON27]

Well,i think lindsay looks much healther after gaining few pounds,but janet...

Im so lucky that i am skiny

[Tiara]

They all look much better but Janet is Fat now, sorry, theres no nice way of saying it, thats one big ass!

[SVZ]

has it really been 3 years since she toured?

[saimamom]

This article is trying to say, "Look how fat they are now" rather than "look how much better they look now."

[PlasticGirl]

I think jessica is looking a bit chunky too, her thighs at least.

[misskris]

these weights are soo off. i'm 5'1'' and i looked like jessica when i weighed 120 lbs. in the first pic i bet she's barely tipping 105 at most.

[A*O]

I just watched a truly terrible TV movie called Supernova starring nobody you've ever heard of, but among the cast was Tea Carrerra (sp?) the uber hot chick in the Waynes World movies. My God, the years have NOT been kind........

[SVZ]

I just watched a truly terrible TV movie called Supernova starring nobody you've ever heard of, but among the cast was Tea Carrerra (sp?) the uber hot chick in the Waynes World movies. My God, the years have NOT been kind........

A*O is that the weird space movie? Where they go to some library? I really want to see that again...

[A*O]

The last bit of the movie is a bit vague - I fell asleep! - but it's about when the sun is about to turn supernova and the world is about to end and the hero's wife/daughter are threatened by the rapist who was on his way to death row when his van overturned in some cosmic ray incident and he decides to track them down............ now you know why I fell asleep. It's a totally crap movie.

[tofucheesecake]

They're always off on their numbers in these magazines. I'm the same height as Lindsay, and while I think she gained a bit, she's still something like a size 2, and probably 125 MAX.