Marlon Brando vs. Paul Newman

[Brando]

In their prime, who does it for you?

Here are a couple pictures to help your decision.

[mistify]

That is way too tough a decision. They were both unbelievably sexy and gorgeous..'

I went with Paul though, cause he aged WAY better.

[Brando]

You must only take into accout their prime, not what they looked like when they aged.

[mistify]

That was way too hard, because both were just HOT! Brando oozed sexiness and Paul has those eyes!!!

That is my opinion. Brando was pretty scary looking at the end It is kinda hard not too forget.

[tiggle]

Marlon Brando, for sure
I mean, look at those lips..

[Chalet]

It's just that I've never stood in front of a wearing only jockey shorts Brando...so...

[HWBL]

I can't decide. They were both too hot for different reasons. Young Paul's face was esthetically more perfect than Marlon's, but Brando's more robust physique was more attractive. Paul had better hair, they were about the same height (5'8"-5'9"-ish). I just can't pick one......

[mistify]

I think Paul was just beautiful. I think he is better looking, but you cannot discount Brando's sexiness. Plus I agree^^ those lips..

[PaintTheTownRed]

I can't vote right now, I have to think about it. It's too tough! Both were so hot.

[Icepik]

I lived with a guy that looked almost exactly like Brando in his young days, and he cheated on me, so I have a "hate-on" for him and Brando ( ), so, I have to say Paul Newman.

[Aella]

In their prime, Brando, NO CONTEST.

However, Paul Newman has aged extremely well, while Brando...eh. It was depressing.

[DeChayz]

Newman!!! Brando was hot, no doubt, but very neanderthal-ish. Paul Newman was sexy-classy and sooooo fine

[Laurent]

Newman in his "Cat on a Hot Tin Roof" days can beat almost anybody.

[MrsDark]

I can't decide. They were both too hot for different reasons. Young Paul's face was esthetically more perfect than Marlon's, but Brando's more robust physique was more attractive. Paul had better hair, they were about the same height (5'8"-5'9"-ish). I just can't pick one......

I agree. Poll says sex appeal though, which is more than just looks. Tough call but I went with Brando. I guess I kind of secretly dig neanderthal-ish types. Later years it'd have been Newman for sure though!

[Lobelia]

If you could get into my brain & Brillo out my knowledge that Marlon Brando was a batshit lunatic, then I would vote for him. Unfortunately, I cannot get past my memories of him as a deranged narcissistic shamu, so Newman it is.