Tried three yesterday. Benefit won. Makeup Forever Aqua Cream pots were a big greasy mess.
I already have one Bobbi Brown cream shadow pot - in Antique Gold for fall/winter, gorgeous color. BB doesn't spread as smoothly as Benefit's but the colors are sophisticated. Benefit is creamy and when it dries it stays on big time.
I wear it with Mac Powerpoint liner in Buried Treasure. It's an olive black.
Second one from the left:
The Benefit color is RSVP