ELF (Eyes, Lips, Face) is my favorite cheapie cosmetics line...they have a soothing lip gloss that is one of the better formulas out there. Most of their products are only $1 and are not tested on animals.
Their idea of "fur-free" is a little different, bur nonetheless a good one. They are helping the Protect the Seals campaign, which works to end the cruelty towards baby seals.
Here's a link to the product: http://www.eyeslipsface.com/elfshop/humanesociety.asp