Woman allegedly attacked by NYC cop over sick dog

[Honey]

Chrissie Brodigan, 32, takes the "L" train every day to work in Manhattan and says she brings along her partially blind pug, "Dempsey" in a special carrying bag. But Monday night, in the intense heat, she says the dog threw up. So, she took him out of the bag in the Bedford Ave. Station and that's when a transit cop named Joel Witriol allegedly confronted her, demanding I.D. that she didn't have.
"I said if you're not gonna give me a ticket, I'm out of here," said Brodigan to PIX News. "Then he pushed me against the wall and handcuffed me."
In addition, Brodigan also claims Witriol kicked her ankles apart.
Another subway passenger, Melissa Randazzo, started snapping photos with her I-phone and called 911 as the situation heated up.



"He was very agitated, saying the same thing, "If you're gonna act like a woman, I'm gonna treat you like a woman," said Brodigan.
But another commuter who saw the scene reportedly said Brodigan cursed at the officer and hurled anti-Semitic remarks at him.
"I didn't notice he was Jewish," said Brodigan. "I said he wasn't acting human and he had problem with women."
Brodigan says she was physically carried out of the subway station by cops - getting three tickets at a transit precinct.
When PIX News tried to reach to Officer Witriol at home, a woman who answered the phone told us "he's not available." But a reporter Wednesday asked Police Commissioner Ray Kelly about allegations the woman was manhandled.
"There's no indication of that," said Kelly. "That's an appropriate issue to be referred to the civilian complaint review board and we've referred it to them."
Chrissy Brodigan, though, has one last question about protocol for sick dogs.
"Is it humane to leave the dog in the crate, or is it more humane to take the dog out of the crate?" she asked. "I don't mind paying $75 dollars for breaking a rule."

Woman Allegedly Attacked by NYC Cop Over Sick Dog - WPIX

[Grimmlok]

next time yank out his lil curls

[Mivvi21]

Cops overreact to everything anymore.

[NicoleWasHere]

And the cops wonder why people hate them.

[buttmunch]

Was that really a Hasidic cop? Have never run into one of those in the States. And yeah, cops might just want to think about calming the fuck down every so often.

[Charmed Hour]

Originally Posted by buttmunch

Was that really a Hasidic cop? Have never run into one of those in the States. And yeah, cops might just want to think about calming the fuck down every so often.

Yes, he's Hasidic. NYPD's first one, hired on about a year or so ago. Witnesses gave conflicting accounts of how the arrest went down...many said she called him things like, "dirty Jew", etc. which she didn't deny. She said she doesn't remember saying it if she did.

City law says the dog needs to be in a carrier while on public transport. He's empowered with enforcing those laws.

[buttmunch]

Yeah, there's always rules and laws that need to be followed but sometimes common sense should come into play. Also, cops are really over-reacting these days.

[Wiseguy]

At first, I thought it was also another case of cops over reacting. But if she started freaking out and hurling racist remarks at him, then she got what she deserved.

[Fly_On_TheWall]

Is the dog ok?

[Charmed Hour]

Originally Posted by buttmunch

Yeah, there's always rules and laws that need to be followed but sometimes common sense should come into play. Also, cops are really over-reacting these days.

I agree re: common sense. For me common sense is to follow the law, put the dog in his carrier. If he's ill, I highly doubt a cramped, hot, smelly and swaying NYC subway is the way to go. People need to have consideration for fellow passengers as well. I'd prefer not to get in the car that has the unrestrained sick dog in it.

I don't see him as overreacting. He asked for ID and for her to put the dog in the carrier. She freaked out and was arrested. IMO, she overreacted (based on what's been reported).

[witchcurlgirl]

I didn't notice he was Jewish," said Brodigan

guess she though the peyes and yarmulke were just a fashion statement

[llamamama]

^^
exactly.