Hillary Duff in a black bikini on a beach in Hawaii 23/06/09

[sparkly]

I'd rather see every girl in Hollywood look like this than anorexic junkies (like most of them). She looks like an average girl.

[Geest]

no worries when she sees the pics, she goes on a meth diet and everyone on gossip sites can cry out in unison how disgustingly thin/skinny she is.

My humble opinion is that she should tone her abs and arms a little, love the legs - all in all a girl about a BMI of 22-23.

Certainly fat by H'wood standards but healthy by mine.

[lisalucy69]

She looks perfectly fine. Not skin and bones and not fat.

[bellini]

She's not fat but does have an unfortunate figure. So much like Britney. No waist, stumpy legs. I do think she's a pretty girl though.

[celeb_2006]

Indeed looks normal but built like a fireplug.

Alas, as we know, here is the schedule for y'all at GR:

July 4th- Hillary Duff shoots back at her critics for their criticism of her candid beach bikini pictures. Claims that she's happy with how she looks, it's no one's damned business. Her fans resoundingly respond with words of support, lurves, and encouragement.

July 10th- Secretly hires a personal trainer and goes on a mass starvation diet and boot camp exercise routine.

September 20th- People magazine: Hillary Duff, how I lost 20 pounds!!!

Lather, rinse and repeat.

Again, is there anything more predictable in this universe???

[VanessaLapierre]

She look good

Btw, my first language is french and Petit-ami mean boyfriend and Petite-amie mean girlfriend :p

[mtlebay]

Originally Posted by Folieadeux

Is that a breast implant scar in the fifth pic?

Good one. I agree w/ you--looks like a PS scar.

Which, in these pics, ITA why she had them done--balances more w/ her frame.

[sophie]

porker

[llamamama]

What's with the tiny bikini bottoms? She'd look better if they were larger.