I just received the wrap dress in XS in asphalt and eggplant; I love them. They're a great basic. I'm 5ft and 90-95lbs and the xs fits really great. I read more positive than negative reviews on the site but I had to see for myself.
I could really care about other issues at American Apparel; all I know is I just got two great dresses and I plan on getting a few more colors.