Same dress celebrities - Oh the shame! - Page 2

EvilMonkey · November 23rd, 2005, 07:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by moocow

1. Posh if you bag her face - Cameron's shoes are hideous
2. Angelina. I've noticed that hair hanging down in the front doesn't go well in any of these, and even though I prefer the normal waist look instead of higher waist, Ang carries it better.
3. Fergie's figure is better and I like her shoes better
4. Jamelia's boobs hang funny - Tara wears the dress better, but she needs a brush and some makeup
5. Scarlett - I think that comparing them, Marcia needs some jewelry at the neckline
6. Charlize's shoulders look wide in that pic, but Naomi looks wrong to me there, so I say Charlize
7. Kim's gaps too much at the chest, Iman looks more sophisticated
8. Nicole - it makes Scarlett's chest look too low, she needs more coverage in that dress
9. Sienna's hair detracts, but Naomi's is too tight in the chest, so Sienna (much as I can't stand her)
10. Minnie. That kind of top, if you don't have the cleavage, it makes you look flat

Not as much detail noticed re shoes n makeup....Im a guy come on!!

But anyway I agree with this order.

jtoland · November 23rd, 2005, 07:56 PM

1. Posh
2. Angie
3. Fergie
4. Jamelia
5. Marcia
6. Naomi
7. Kim
8. Nicole
9. Sienna
10. Minnie

And for the record, I think all of the dresses are ugly.

Lobelia · November 23rd, 2005, 08:32 PM

I would just like for Naomi to stuff her nipple back into her dress, please.

suede · November 23rd, 2005, 08:46 PM

1 - Posh
2 - Angie
3 - Neither but pressed Fergie
4 - Neither period. ACK
5 - Marcia
6 - Both, if pressed Naomi just because of the contrast of her skin.
7 - Neither period.
8 - Nicole
9 - Neither, it's damn ugly
10 - see 9

sass4prez · November 24th, 2005, 03:44 PM

You know, one thing I noticed when looking through those pics is that in the ones where you have an American wearing the same dress as a non-American (brit, or whereever Fergie is from...), the American woman's face always really stands out. Her face and her personality... whereas some of the other non-Americans, they seem to sort of take a backseat to the dress.

I dunno if I'm explaining it right... I think sometimes the non-Americans may technically have a better body for the dress, or make the dress look better, but ...for the Americans, their faces seem to OVERSHADOW the dress.

Just notes from a neutral Canadian.

echox2 · November 24th, 2005, 07:14 PM

Ick, looks like Rainbow Brite exploded all over them.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tiara

Who do you think wears them best?

NawdleZouss · November 24th, 2005, 11:29 PM

1. Cameron. Although that's a typical example of a scroll-down. BURN. THOSE. SHOES.

2. As much as I hate to say this, Angelina, my pet, the dress makes her look long and lanky. As if a jabberwocky came and ate her hips.

3. Loathe them both. Especially the stick figure on the left. But it fits her better.

4. Plain gross. And the woman on the right has her breasts pushed up to the stratosphere. I fear for my life.

5. Another sad, sad moment, but I'm going to have to go with Scarlett. Again, better fit, better shoes, better jewelery.

6. What is it with beautiful celebs and ill-fitting dresses? Linebacker shoulders. Naomi, for sure.

7. Kim wins.

Although they both look dumpy.

8. Yes! Nicole!

When was that pic taken, she looks like a human?!

9. Sienna. Although it's a fugly dress, Naomi nipple can creep anyone out.

10. Whoever Jodi is, she looks like something my cat threw up the other day, after a long, hard struggle. Eww. Just gross.

By default alone, Minnie wins this round.

Great thread.

muchlove · November 25th, 2005, 01:16 AM

1. Posh
2. Angelina
3. Fergie
4. Tara
5. Scarlett
6. Naomi
7. Iman
8. Nicole
9. Naomi
10. Minnie

Tiara · November 25th, 2005, 07:18 AM

What exactly was Cameron thinking when she put those shoes on?? She should have wore black ones or even red ones would have gone with her lipstick but blue?? I'm just so confused.

AyanEva · November 26th, 2005, 04:32 AM

1) Horror of horrors, I'm actually going to go with Cameron. Posh's grapefruit halves are too noticeable and I like the splash of color provided by Cameron's shoes.
2) You know who I'm going to choose, so I won't even say it. I've always loved the empire waist.
3)Fugly dress, but I'm going with Fergie; she fills the dress out better and her hair matches well with it. Mischa's little booties are awful.
4)Fugly tie. Jamelia presents an overall better image and wears the bottom of the dress better, she looks great overall, but her shoes suck. Tara wears the top of the dress better, has cute shoes, but her hair sucks.
5)Edge, Marcia. I like the color on Cameron's skin a little better, but you can't beat how gorgeous Marcia's hair looks with that dress and I like the lack of a necklace and shoes. Simple, yet elegant.
6)Charlize, very statuesque (sp?). It's not a runway, Naomi...you look like RuPaul's sister.
7)Iman, although the dress makes her hips look a little big, she fills it out well. Kim looks washed out because her skin's so pale and the dress is dark; also, she doesn't have Iman's figure.
8)Nicole, though I'm not really sure why. The dress just seems to look better on her.
9)Another FUGLY dress. I'm going with Naomi, just barely;, although I'd really rather pick Sienna. However, Sienna looks like a little girl playing dress up in her mother's wedding gown. Too much dress on too small a frame. Naomi is larger, although the top of her dress is 2 sizes too small and the top of Sienna's dress looks better.
10)Minnie. The dress suits her and I like her shoes. Are those flip-flops that Jodie's wearing?

AyanEva