I would have believed the turkey baster theory if it happened after their marriage - they made a big deal at the time about Katie saving herself for her husband, and I'm sure if the plan was to pass her artificially inseminated kid off as their naturally conceived offspring, they would have drawn the whole thing out to get as much publicity as possible - a big wedding, their joy at the pregnancy, all that crap that the tabs would lap up.
I doubt either knew she was already pregnant when they met, but the chances were the baby would easily pass as Tom's (based on most theories about who Katie may have slept with before she met Tom ie. Chris Klein or Josh Hartnett). Maybe we were supposed to believe that Katie was so overcome by Tom's studliness that she couldn't wait to give it up, and that his mighty OT seed knocked her up first try?
I just don't see Tom sending his new girlfriend off to the fertility doctor clutching a freezer bag full of his cousin's jizz.
|